The impact of AI on surface design
In the vibrant world of surface pattern design, where creativity knows no bounds, the tale of Rosie, a distinguished watercolor artist and surface pattern designer from New South Wales, unfolds. Renowned for her unique portrayal of Australia’s breathtaking coastal scenes, Rosie’s artwork is a homage to her serene surroundings in Bondi Beach. Her signature coastal style, a fresh breath of Australian summer, extends beyond mere representations of sand, sea, sky, and rocks. She has her own special technique—layering white watercolour paint to create a whitewashed look—that sets her apart.
However, in this era where art and technology intertwine, Rosie’s distinctive style encounters an unexpected challenge. You see, another designer, inspired by Rosie’s aesthetic, turns to an advanced AI program.
Their request?
To replicate Rosie’s coastal patterns in her unmistakable style.
Given Rosie’s prominence, with her designs scattered across the internet, the task proves easy for the AI. The result is astonishingly accurate, producing artwork so similar to Rosie’s that it sparks confusion. Admirers struggle to distinguish between the original and the AI-generated designs, with some even speculating if the newcomer’s work is either Rosie’s or indicative of a talent matching hers.
This scenario illuminates a critical junction in the intersection of art, technology, and law. Despite the apparent infringement on Rosie’s unique style, the stark reality she faces is that copyright law, as it currently stands, protects the expression of a design rather than the idea, style, or technique behind it. (For more about this read: https://sharongivoni.com.au/i-like-your-style-the-blurred-lines-between-artistic-expression-and-copyright-law/).
This legal limitation leaves Rosie, and artists like her, in a precarious position where their distinctive styles can be replicated without recourse. This demonstrates that there is a significant gap in copyright law when it comes to AI.
The implications for surface pattern designers are profound.
In a field that thrives on originality and personal expression, the ability of technology to replicate and distribute distinctive styles at the click of a button poses both a challenge and a call to action. For designers, the evolving landscape necessitates a proactive approach to safeguarding their creative identity. Here are some strategies for artists to navigate these waters:
Build a Brand, Not Just a Style: Establishing a strong personal brand can create an unmistakable identity that transcends the artwork itself. This involves storytelling, consistent communication with your audience, and engagement that enhances your personal narratives that just cant be replicated by AI.
Document Your Creative Process: Think about publicly sharing the journey behind your designs, from concept sketches to final pieces, can help establish a documented timeline of your creative evolution. This reinforces the connection between you as the artist and your style but also fosters a deeper connection with your audience.
Diversify Your Artistic Expression: While maintaining a signature style is vital, periodically introducing new elements or techniques can keep your work ahead of imitators. Innovation is harder to replicate. It can distinguish your genuine creations from those mimicked by AI.
Legal Safeguards: While copyright might not cover styles or techniques, registering your individual designs as desisngs or trade marks, can offer additional layers of protection. Consulting with a legal professional specialising in intellectual property rights can provide tailored strategies to safeguard your work.
Community Advocacy: There’s strength in numbers. Joining forces with other artists and organisations to advocate for more robust legal protections for artistic styles and techniques can lead to legislative changes. The creative community can initiate discussions, propose solutions, and push for reforms that better protect artists in the digital age.
The message
The case of Rosie is not just a cautionary tale but a rallying cry for surface pattern designers and artists everywhere. It highlights the need for a balanced dialogue between the advancement of technology and the protection of creative rights. As artists navigate this new frontier, adapting their strategies and engaging in advocacy will be key to ensuring that their artistic voices remain distinct and protected in the digital era.
Conclusion
While the digital age offers surface pattern designers unprecedented opportunities to showcase their work, it also presents new challenges in protecting their unique artistic identities.
Rosie’s story although, fictional. serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between inspiration and imitation, urging artists to remain vigilant and proactive in safeguarding their creative expressions. The journey ahead is complex, but with the right strategies and collective action, artists can navigate these challenges and continue to thrive in an ever-evolving landscape.
This article is not to be relied on as a substitute for legal advice.
Sharon Givoni boasts over two decades of extensive experience in Intellectual Property (IP) and Commercial Law, offering her services to a wide array of clients across Australia and internationally. Specialising in the laws relating to surface design, Sharon acts for numerous designers, providing expert legal advice and competitive pricing. Her expertise encompasses a broad spectrum of legal matters, including drafting and negotiating commercial agreements, handling contentious and non-contentious IP issues, and giving copyright advice. Sharon’s approach to law is encapsulated in her own brands “Legal Ease, Not Legalese” and “Turning Your Ideas into Assets”, reflecting her commitment to demystifying the complex world of IP law and transforming creative concepts into tangible, protected properties. https://sharongivoni.com.au
How AI Works – A quick guide to surface designers from Sharon Givoni
Imagine AI as a really smart robot that learns by looking at a lot of pictures. Let’s say you show this robot thousands of pictures of cats. By studying those pictures, it starts to understand what cats generally look like—their shapes, sizes, and colors. After it learns enough, you can ask this robot to draw a picture of a cat, and it’ll create a new cat picture that it’s never seen before, based on what it learned.
Now, apply this idea to surface design patterns. If you show the AI lots of designs by Rosie, the AI examines all these designs closely. It notices how Rosie uses colors, how she depicts the beach, and how she layers her watercolors to create that whitewashed look. The AI learns Rosie’s style.
Then, when someone asks the AI to create a new design in Rosie’s style, the AI uses what it learned to generate a new design. This design mimics Rosie’s way of painting beaches, even down to the details like the texture of the sand and the color of the water, making it look very similar to Rosie’s work.
AI does this by using algorithms—basically, complex sets of rules and instructions. These algorithms analyze the input (in this case, Rosie’s designs) to identify patterns and characteristics. Then, when it’s time to create something new, the AI uses another set of algorithms to generate artwork that matches those patterns and characteristics.
So, in layman’s terms, AI learns by looking at a lot of examples and then applies what it learns to create new things that can look remarkably like something a specific person would make, even if that person never actually made it.
Looking for comprehensive legal advice on a contract?
DesignWise Template Package
Sharon Givoni Consulting has had over 25 years’ experience in this area.
Our DesignWise package is specifically for surface designers, combining essential design templates with personalised guidance and legal coaching.
Priced at $1200, this package includes a Client Agreement, catering to projects of varying sizes and nature.
Understanding that templates alone often lead to gaps in protection when not utilised correctly, we have included a one-hour consultation. This session not only helps in correctly applying these agreements to your business but also provides vital legal advice on copyright law, a fundamental aspect of a surface designer’s business concerning the licensing or selling of designs.
The consultation covers important topics such as domain names, trade marks, and business names, offering strategies to protect your brand effectively. This approach ensures you’re not just receiving documents, but a full understanding of how to leverage them for your business’s legal safety and brand protection.
Before purchasing, I encourage reading our Terms & Conditions to understand how best to integrate this package into your operations. This package is an investment in securing your design business on solid legal and operational grounds, offering peace of mind and clarity for both you and your clients.
Contact Sharon Givoni at sharon@iplegal.com.au
